Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$5
Our everyday classic, soft-baked with plenty of chocolate chips.
Order similarFresh this week
This Week's Offerings
Everything below is baked in-house and in stock right now. Our menu rotates with the seasons — see something you love? Order it or use it as inspiration for a custom creation.
Cookies
Cookies
Bishcoff Cookie
$6
Cookie made with spiced speculoos-style Biscoff flavor.
Order similarCookies
Dulche De Leche Cookie
$6
Soft cookie swirled with sweet dulce de leche.
Order similarCookies
DF Chocolate Cookie
$6
Dairy-free chocolate cookie.
Order similarPies & Specialty
Pies & Specialty
Oatmeal Cream Pie
$10
Two chewy oatmeal cookies with vanilla cream.
Order similarPies & Specialty
Caramel Apple Pie Sandwich
$10
Caramel apple pie filling between two cookies.
Order similarPies & Specialty
Gluten Free Oatmeal Cream Pie
$13
Our oatmeal cream pie made gluten free.
Order similarPies & Specialty
GF Caramel Apple
$13
Gluten-free caramel apple treat.
Order similarPantry
Pantry
Dozen Eggs
$6
One dozen fresh local eggs.
Order similarPantry
Car Stickers
$5
TLSBM house sticker — show your bakery pride.
Order similarPantry
Spicy Menace Salsa
$7
House spicy salsa.
Order similarPantry
Sweet Sting
$7
House sweet-heat sauce.
Order similarPantry
Buttermilk Bouledard Ranch
$8
House-made buttermilk ranch.
Order similarPantry
Cottage Batch Mayo
$12
House-made mayonnaise.
Order similarMerch
Merch
Cow Bell
$25
TLSBM cow bell.
Order similarMerch
Tumblers
$15
TLSBM tumbler.
Order similar💛 Offerings rotate weekly based on seasonal ingredients and what we're excited to create. Don't see what you're looking for? Reach out — we love custom requests.